KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Toilet Review
KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Comfort Height Two-Piece Elongated 1.28 gpf Toilet
The best selling two-piece comfort height toilet from the KOHLER Memoirs series. This HET has everything you wish for with an elegant look to match your Victorian style or contemporary bathroom design. Available in 6 shades of white, including white of course and Black to match your gothic themed bathroom. It certainly adds that touch of class to your prized bathroom you would enjoy every moment of it.
Apart from its appearance, this squarish Memoirs Stately toilet packs a powerful flush and pleasantly quiet. A great water saver and extremely easy to install and maintain. Designed around KOHLER’s winning features and specifications, this 2-piece elongated toilet has received great reviews by users in the major online shopping portals and forums.
So what are the features and specification that make this KOHLER Memoirs toilet such a hit? Surely there must be some disadvantages that the fastidious lot would love to chew on. Let’s find out.
NOTE: It’s a long post so please use the Table of Content and anchor for your easy browsing.
What’s The Big Deal About This KOHLER K-3817-0?
With KOHLER Memoirs it all starts with style. Its classic design provides the perfect look for traditional homes. And for those who doesn’t like to mix and match too much, the Memoirs Stately toilet also matches the other Memoirs line of bathroom fixtures, like the Memoirs sinks, faucets and baths. Makes it very easy to coordinate, and you spend less time tracking down the brands and models when replacement is needed.
The real benefits of this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately toilet lie in its powerful flushing system and bowl design. Instead of a standard flapper valve, this Memoirs toilet features a patented flush engine, The AquaPiston.
Unlike conventional flush valves, there’s no flapper which means no leaks to be concern with and water flow is much stronger. It’s just full out power. In fact Memoirs flushes four times more than the average adult needs. Plus this KOHLER Memoirs Stately toilet provides 50% more rinse than previous KOHLER models, giving you a cleaner bowl after every flush.
Now let’s talk about water savings. This WaterSense certified toilet features a 1.28 gallon per flush, which means you’ll save about $100 per year on your water bill compared to a 3.5 gallon toilet (if you are still using an old toilet model before 1994 or earlier). And you can save about 20% of water compared to a 1.6 gpf toilet.
Another great feature of the Memoirs toilet is the Comfort Heights seating. KOHLER comfort height toilet is about the height of a standard chair, making it much easier to sit down and stand up. It makes a lot of difference for the elderly and people who has leg injuries. They will love this feature.
Features & Specifications Overview
The Flush That Really Flush – The AquaPiston Advantage
The AquaPiston flush technology uses a canister valve in place of the conventional flapper valve. The advantage of the canister valve is its 360 degrees opening that allows water to flow through in greater volume faster as compared to the flapper valve.
High speed and volume is the basis of great energy force. When applied to toilet flushing, it translate into powerful gush of water that pushes waste out easily and creates a strong siphon that is capable of removing heavy loads. Which is why all of KOHLER AquaPiston toilets has a MaP rating of 1000, the highest MaP score for great flushing performance .
Another advantage of the AquaPiston canister design is its ease of operation. It is lighter to lift the cylindrical tower versus the flapper. You can feel the lighter touch on the trip lever. A quick flick on the lever will lift and open the tower valve quicker allowing more water to flow through in a shorter time period. This is especially useful when flushing heavy loads. Hence you can easily control the flush on the trip lever by varying the force you exert on it.
Apart from the flush engine design, the bowl plays a significant part in rinsing efficiency. The elongated bowl rim is designed to allow water to flow into the bowl from all sides which makes bowl rinsing extremely effective, besides assisting in making the flush much more powerful.
The Advantage Of Having The Largest Water Surface Area
Aiming is less of a concern because you are unlikely going to miss the large water spot. Measuring 11.75″ by 9.5″, this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs toilet has the largest water surface area compared to its competition.
Bowl streaking rarely happens and waste are always submerged in water even when you had a ton to evacuate. This is beneficial in keeping the bowl clean as the water keeps the waste loosely adhered to the bowl surface. With the powerful AquaPiston flush, waste is easily flush out of the bowl leaving nothing behind, every time. This greatly reduces unsightly skid marks from forming.
Another advantage of having a large water surface is odor filtering. It prevents the piling up of waste above the water during a heavy session. Thus odor is contained and prevented from filling the surrounding air. The next person who comes in right after you will never know you have just done your number 2.
Typical Toilet Installation
If you have installed any toilet previously, you will find this KOHLER Memoirs Stately toilet a breeze to install. Especially toilets with exposed trapways, they are plumbers’ pet job. They get it right the first time, every time.
Even if this is your first try at installing a toilet, you can hardly go wrong. You just need to make sure the floor is leveled and the toilet flange sitting on the drain hole has got to be flushed with the floor surface. Otherwise there are always the correction materials you need such as toilet shims and flange extender.
And the installation manual is easy to follow. It has 10 steps with clear description and illustrative image for every step. At the top of the manual is a list of simple tools and material you need for the installation.
Of course not everyone has the interest to install anything, especially a toilet. Hiring a plumber to do what they do best is always the best option. And getting a skilled and friendly plumber not only makes your day, you get a peace of mind knowing this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately toilet is going to last for years to come.
Disadvantages Of KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Toilet
Before we can objectively deal with a product disadvantage, it is fair to define what a disadvantage really encompasses.
In this case perhaps, instead of calling ‘Disadvantage’ it would seem more appropriate to refer to it as Flaws. The difference are, flaws are not necessary a byproduct of design. It can be a manufacturing flaw, a quality control flaw or a logistical flaw that render a product problematic to be used normally as per its design.
A design flaw, however, is a more relative term for disadvantage, it is usually consistent in manifestation. For example, the disadvantage of a two-piece toilet is the joint area of the tank and bowl. It tend to accumulate dirt, mold and bacteria, and it is difficult to clean. Whereas a one-piece toilet eliminates this problem, but the trade-off is, the tank and bowl can’t be replaced separately.
So what are the flaws of this KOHLER Memoirs Stately toilet?
When a solution is offered to solve a problem it can sometime lead to a new problem, but usually acceptable with a little change in usage pattern. It is a matter of getting used to it. Like the metaphor of the two-piece and one-piece toilet example mentioned above, the ‘disadvantage’ is perhaps the AquaPiston canister valve design.
The canister valve opens by lifting a cylindrical tower to let water flow through without obstruction. Unlike the flapper design, it is reactive to your control of the trip lever. The valve closes immediately once you release the trip lever. If you want a full flush you will need to hold down the lever for about 1 second. This, has got several complaints from users who are used to pulling the lever and release instantly for a full flush with their flapper valve.
But in reality, the canister valve provides a more powerful flush, and more durable because there is no flapper that needs to be replaced. The trade-off is a mere second more, but you get a clean flush and less replacement parts to worry about. So is this a disadvantage or a flaw? You decide.
Now moving on to the real flaws.
You have read every so often that toilets; arrived broken, takes forever to arrive, unhelpful or rude customer service, missing parts, seat not included, seat made of cheap plastic…the list goes on. None of these are relevant to the toilet performance. But they are real problems.
To get to the bottom of these issues, it will probably take several man-years and plenty of resources. And still, there is no guarantee everything can or will be solved. In that case let’s not dwell on. Instead, you should take proactive measures to make sure you are getting what you have paid for.
What measures are needed?
Always check your toilet immediately upon arrival. DO NOT wait till you are about to install it, or after installing it. Take photographs or videos or both to document the state of the packaging, number of packages and check for possible defects. If you will, do a flush test to check for internal defects that is not visible on the exterior.
You will incur more cost and waste valuable time once you have installed and discovered there are problems with the toilet. And the endless to and fro debate on who’s at fault when you encounter a die hard book-obeying customer service.
Pros & Cons Overview
KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Two-Piece Elongated Toilet
|Bowl Width ~15″||Comfortable seating – Especially for large build person.||–|
|Flushing Mechanism||Powerful AquaPiston Flushing System with high rinsing efficiency.||Single flush – Uses same water amount for flushing liquid waste.|
|Surface Finisih||Conventional glazed surface.||–|
|Exposed Trapway||–||Fairly difficult to clean those clefts formed by the trapway.|
|2-piece Toilet||Tank and bowl can be replaced separately. Less weight to lift during installation.||Tank to bowl seam – accumulates mold, bacteria & dirt. Fairly difficult to clean without removing the tank.|
|Elongated Bowl||Comfortable to use. Especially for guys.||–|
|Rough-in||12″ – common size.||–|
|Water Surface Area||Large – 11.75″ x 9.5″.||–|
|Toilet Seat||–||SoftClose seat included.|
|ADA Compliant (Comfort Height)||Comfortable seat level – easy to get up and seated.||–|
|WaterSense Certified||Yes – Save 20% more water.||–|
|MaP Rating||1000 – Capable of removing 1000 grams of waste in a single flush.||–|
|Price||Great value.||High for colors other than white.|
Common Problems Faced By Some Users
Broken toilets on arrival seemed to be the most complained as seen on reviews at both Amazon and Home Depot. One user at Home Depot even had to endure 3 deliveries before finally had an unbroken toilet at his door step.
Nothing much you can do to prevent situation like this. It’s up to KOHLER or Amazon and Home Depot to straighten things up in this aspect. But it’s frustrating enough. You will probably continue to hear broken toilet complaints until such time when they really feel the pain (losses) of making toilet replacement as their second business.
The other complain is a little remote. But when 2 or more users had the same problem, then it can’t be classified as isolated cases.
In this case there are at least 5 users at Amazon and 1 from Home Depot discovered the tank is leaning forward, away from the wall when mounted. Their plumbers were unable to do much to rectify this issue. It was not known what was the real cause of it, so a quality control flaw is the most likely thing in the mind of the affected users.
Again, despite it’s going to sound like a broken record, please check your toilet thoroughly at the first instance when they arrived. Good thing you have all these reviews to lead you to the places you need to check. Otherwise frustration could well be the freebies that the sellers are sending to you.
The user reviews of this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately toilet has gotten some decent ratings both at Amazon and Home Depot. But the reviews at Amazon is a little more positive than in Home Depot; while this KOHLER toilet review was written. Scoring an impressive 4.2 stars rating in Amazon compared to 4.1 at Home Depot.
Needless to say the 5 stars reviews are all from satisfied users. Likewise the 4 stars are some what satisfied with the impeccable design but are generally forgiving with a little imperfection. This is where you could use the reviews to form your buying decision as they are genuinely unbiased.
The 3 stars reviews are always balanced with a mix of positives and negatives. If you are still undecided after reading those 5 and 4 stars reviews, these 3 stars reviews should more or less help in your decision making.
Making up around 10% are the 2 stars and 1 star reviews. You guessed it, they are the least satisfied users or perhaps the majority are just unlucky to have received a less than perfect toilet. But their opinions should not be taken lightly. What goes to them can happen to you too (go touch some wood).
But rest assured, you are dealing with some of America’s best managed companies who value customer relationship more than anything. If ever you are not too happy with their products or services, give them a shout. You will never be left in the lurch.
Though user reviews are important references, take it with a pinch of salt. Not denying some reviews are there with an axe to grind, the majority are still valid opinions. The best toilet review, however, is always your own experience with the product itself.
Where to buy this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Two-Piece Elongated Toilet
You probably have your preference when comes to buying a toilet online. That’s a great decision as online offers are generally more competitive than offline retail stores.
Whether you are going to Amazon, Home Depot or Lowes, the prices and service rendered are hyper competitive. It doesn’t matter how negative some reviews are, they are mostly biased. Everyday somewhere someone is going to get pissed at the slightest hint and off they let go, usually onto the review page. And it’s easy to spot them.
Everyday somewhere someone is going to get pissed at the slightest hint and off they let go, usually onto the review page.
Amazon Price Watch
What you see below are offers by Amazon sellers with the lowest price. Please note that the prices MAY or MAY NOT include shipping charges.
Note: PRICES COME FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. AND ARE PROVIDED ‘AS IS’ AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Two-Piece Elongated Toilet
Access Parts List ► Memoirs Stately | Parts Viewer K-3817-0
Alternative Toilet Models Price & Features Comparison
KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Comfort Height Two-Piece Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet
American Standard Optum VorMax Complete Right Height 2-piece 1.28 GPF Elongated Toilet
TOTO CST784EF#01 Eco Clayton Comfort Height Two-Piece Toilet with Elongated Bowl
|Flush System||AquaPiston Flushing System||VorMax Flushing System||E-Max Flushing System|
|Glazed Surface||Conventional||EverClean Surface||Conventional|
|Water Usage||1.28 gpf (4.8 lpf)||1.28 gpf (4.8 lpf)||1.28 gpf (4.8 lpf)|
|Water Surface Area||11.75″ x 9.5″||9″ X 8″||10.625″ X 8.25″|
|MaP Rating||1000 grams||1000 grams||500 grams|
|Warranty||One Year Limited Warranty||10 Year Warranty||One Year Limited Warranty|
Have you found the information you need about this KOHLER K-3817-0 Memoirs Stately Toilet? May be you have a question that needs an answer; leave your comments below and let’s discuss. Add to Flipboard Magazine.
Share this Page